ZREPORTS RESEARCH INSTITUTE™ · STATE RANKING STUDY

Best and Worst States for Nursing Home Safety 2026

A ranking of all fifty states and the District of Columbia computed entirely from the federal enforcement record: civil money penalties, inspection deficiencies, fines, abuse citations, and Special Focus status across 14,713 Medicare certified nursing homes. No surveys, no opinions, no facility input.

PUBLISHED 2026-11-22 · SOURCE: CMS PROVIDER DATA CATALOG · BY SHAWN REDD, ZREPORTS RESEARCH INSTITUTE

Key Findings

RANKSTATESAFETY SCOREFACILITIES% WITH FEDERAL PENALTIES% WITH SEVERE DEFICIENCIESAVG DEFICIENCIESAVG FINES / FACILITYCMS AVG STARS
1Alabama96.5224 16.5%23.7%10.2 $13,3973.03
2New Hampshire85.773 32.9%31.5%13.3 $7,6683.03
3Arkansas84.2222 32.9%32.0%17.8 $8,5823.48
4Indiana84.1507 20.9%39.8%23.2 $8,1743.21
5Alaska83.920 30.0%25.0%25.6 $26,5723.55
6Kentucky83.4268 33.6%38.1%11.9 $13,4873.03
7Nebraska80.1180 36.7%37.8%19.2 $12,7612.91
8Georgia79.6356 34.8%38.5%16.7 $12,3092.72
9Tennessee78.2303 33.7%44.2%14.4 $20,6653.07
10Maine77.178 35.9%37.2%30.7 $7,9173.13
11Florida76694 37.3%38.5%19.8 $23,4413.30
12New York75.9596 32.4%41.3%20.5 $23,5463.06
13Arizona75.5140 28.6%35.0%21.2 $9,0453.40
14Nevada69.166 39.4%37.9%32.5 $14,0053.29
15Idaho6880 33.8%55.0%27.0 $12,6883.11
16New Jersey68348 40.5%49.4%23.6 $34,2483.45
17Iowa67.4389 41.4%56.6%20.8 $19,0093.12
18Ohio66.3924 36.1%56.4%31.0 $25,6993.24
19South Carolina65.9187 52.4%53.5%12.4 $14,7473.09
20Massachusetts64.6341 45.5%51.0%28.0 $33,0303.11
21Louisiana62.7266 50.4%46.6%24.3 $45,5742.60
22Virginia61.9289 38.1%56.1%38.6 $23,4553.07
23Mississippi60.4203 54.2%58.1%18.4 $15,9692.75
24Oklahoma59.6283 52.7%56.9%22.8 $17,8432.66
25California59.21,165 41.0%50.8%49.7 $23,3663.21
26Minnesota58.8338 45.6%66.9%23.4 $24,4883.20
27Pennsylvania58.3656 45.9%53.2%31.5 $26,7693.03
28North Carolina58.1420 55.7%56.4%17.9 $36,5223.01
29Maryland57.9221 41.2%52.0%52.0 $22,0063.23
30Kansas57.7298 48.7%64.8%27.5 $19,9663.11
31Hawaii56.443 48.8%62.8%33.5 $18,9733.83
32Missouri55.4487 43.7%58.1%36.0 $36,6982.61
33Wisconsin54.7323 45.2%65.6%28.2 $48,2783.07
34Oregon54.4129 49.6%61.2%33.7 $25,4443.17
35West Virginia53.6123 52.8%56.1%40.2 $29,3423.08
36Michigan53.5423 44.2%69.5%32.0 $28,3333.17
37Utah52.397 49.5%70.1%26.5 $23,8433.47
38North Dakota45.972 61.1%72.2%17.1 $27,1313.28
39Connecticut43.4191 57.1%68.1%37.7 $22,7483.01
40Texas42.11,179 67.8%69.6%28.0 $43,0112.75
41Colorado39.8210 60.0%81.4%25.0 $21,7033.12
42Washington38.3193 60.1%70.5%49.9 $48,3453.29
43South Dakota38.398 73.5%76.5%17.5 $39,9892.97
44Rhode Island34.472 72.2%75.0%27.9 $59,3592.93
45New Mexico3368 63.2%69.1%49.9 $48,8882.94
46Montana30.562 74.2%77.4%31.2 $56,7362.95
47Wyoming28.236 77.8%77.8%20.6 $27,7922.80
48Vermont27.633 75.8%69.7%27.8 $87,9562.94
49Delaware25.744 72.7%77.3%36.5 $60,5533.21
50District of Columbia24.817 64.7%82.4%62.2 $70,1183.53
51Illinois13.3668 72.9%86.7%38.1 $108,9902.57

Download the full state table (CSV)

Methodology

Rankings are computed from the CMS Provider Data Catalog record for every active Medicare certified nursing home (14,713 facilities). Six enforcement metrics are normalized across states and combined with fixed, disclosed weights: share of facilities with federal civil money penalties (30%), share with severe deficiencies (25%), average deficiencies per facility (15%), average federal fines per facility (15%), share with a CMS abuse citation icon (10%), and share in the Special Focus Facility program (5%). The Safety Score scales the combined enforcement burden to 100, where 100 represents the lightest burden. Every input is a federal verdict; zReports adds no editorial judgment, and facilities are never contacted and cannot pay to change a result. Data refreshed 2026-11-22.

Cite this study

Redd, S. (2026). Best and Worst States for Nursing Home Safety 2026. zReports Research Institute. https://zreports.org/research/studies/nursing-home-safety-by-state-2026

Companion peer archived analysis: Federal Penalty Patterns Across Medicare Certified Nursing Homes (SSRN 7255298). Datasets and methodology: zreports.org/research. Journalists: state and city level cuts available on request at press@zreports.org. All research CC BY 4.0 — free to republish with attribution.

Check any facility

Every nursing home in this study has a free public record page. Search any facility by name at zreports.org and see its official inspection, penalty, and enforcement history before you decide. Free, no signup, and no facility can pay to change a grade.

ZREPORTS CONSUMER RECORDS DATABASE™ · COMPUTED FROM OFFICIAL RECORDS · FACILITIES ARE NEVER CONTACTED AND CANNOT PAY TO CHANGE SCORES